The Science of Comfort Foods and How to Reframe Their Role

We’ve all heard the phrase “comfort food.” Maybe for you, it’s a warm bowl of pasta, buttery toast, or a slice of cake that reminds you of childhood. These foods are more than just meals, they carry memories, emotions, and a sense of safety. But for those of us in recovery from food addiction, comfort foods can feel like both a friend and a foe.

So why do certain foods feel so comforting, and how can we reframe their role in recovery? Let’s explore the science behind comfort foods, and how you can create new, healthier ways to find comfort without relying on food alone.

Why Comfort Foods Feel So Good

There’s real science behind why comfort foods can be hard to resist:

  • Brain Chemistry - Foods high in sugar, fat, and salt stimulate the brain’s reward system, releasing dopamine, the “feel-good” chemical. This can create a temporary sense of happiness or relief, which is why we often crave these foods when we’re stressed or low.

  • Emotional Associations - Comfort foods often link back to positive memories - family gatherings, childhood treats, or traditions. Eating them can evoke nostalgia and emotional safety.

  • Stress Response - when stressed, our bodies release cortisol. Comfort foods can temporarily lower stress levels, creating the illusion of calm, even if only briefly.

  • Learned Behaviours - Many of us grew up being rewarded with food - a treat for good behaviour, a dessert for finishing dinner. Over time, our brains learn to associate food with comfort, achievement, or love.

The Double-Edged Sword of Comfort Foods in Recovery

While comfort foods may offer short-term relief, they can be a real challenge in recovery. Relying on them to cope with stress or emotion often leads to guilt, shame, and a cycle of cravings. What feels like comfort in the moment can sometimes deepen feelings of loss of control later.

But here’s the good news: comfort itself is not the problem. We all need comfort, especially in recovery. The challenge is finding new, sustainable ways to create it.

Reframing the Role of Comfort in Your Life

The goal isn’t to strip away comfort foods completely, that would ignore the deep emotional ties they hold. Instead, it’s about reframing their role and expanding the ways you find comfort.

1. Redefine What “Comfort” Means

Ask yourself: What does comfort feel like to me, beyond food? Maybe it’s warmth, safety, connection, or calm. Once you know what comfort means for you, it becomes easier to find it in new places.

'What is comfort?' written in yellow in the middle surrounded by a black box. There are two hands with a finger pointing outwards and arrows around it

2. Create a Comfort Toolbox

Build a list of non-food comforts you can turn to when cravings hit. Examples include:

  • Wrapping up in a soft blanket

  • Listening to calming music or a favourite podcast

  • Taking a warm bath

  • Calling a friend

  • Practicing breathwork or mindfulness

Having a go-to list helps you pause and choose a different path when emotions rise.

3. Honour Memories Without Eating Them

If certain foods carry strong emotional ties, try finding ways to honour those memories without the food itself. For example, if baking with a loved one was comforting, maybe recreate the experience by baking something nourishing, or simply sharing the memory with someone you trust.

Cartoon image of a memory book with photos stuck in it. There is clue, scissors, photos, paper clip and scraps of paper around it.

4. Practice Mindful Enjoyment

When you do choose to have a comfort food, try slowing down and enjoying it mindfully. Notice the flavours, textures, and the emotions it brings up. Shifting from autopilot to awareness helps you enjoy the experience without spiralling into guilt or loss of control.

5. Build New Associations

Start linking comfort to healthier or neutral activities. For instance, instead of reaching for chocolate after a stressful day, try going for a walk, stretching, or making a warm herbal tea. Over time, your brain learns new associations for comfort that don’t centre around addictive foods.

Cartoon image of a brain in yellow and orange with lightning bolts coming out of It.

Final Thoughts: Comfort is Still Essential

Food may have been a source of comfort for you in the past, but it doesn’t have to define your recovery. Comfort itself is a need, not a weakness. The shift comes when you allow yourself to find comfort in ways that nurture your body, mind, and soul - not just your cravings.

By reframing the role of comfort foods, you’re not “losing” a coping tool. You’re expanding your toolkit, giving yourself more choices, and building a recovery that supports you in the long run.

At Food Addiction UK, we believe that recovery is about abundance, not restriction. Comfort is part of being human, and you deserve to experience it in ways that truly heal.

Need Support?

Join our community or reach out to talk with others who get it.

You don’t have to do this alone.